Vacancy rate may not give full story
Market focus shifts to
smaller-space leases
by DOUG SMITH, The Charlotte Observer
Office landlords can't help but cringe when
the countywide vacancy rate rises, as it did during the first quarter of
this year.
But some
real estate analysts and leasing agents say the Charlotte area market
might be stronger than vacancy totals indicate.
"I'm very
encouraged with the level of activity we've seen over the past six
months," said David Bailey, executive vice president of Commercial
Carolina Cushman & Wakefield in Charlotte.
"There
are lots of small deals out in the marketplace looking for space," he
said. "We're seeing a lot of new companies that have not been in
Charlotte and some that left and are coming back."
Karnes
Research managing partner Andrew Jenkins said, "Brokers once overlooked
the 5,000 to 10,000 square foot deals, but nowadays they're going after
them."
It takes
a lot of small leases to affect the vacancy rate. But a couple of large
departures or the addition of one large new building can swing it
significantly, he said.
That's
what happened in the first quarter while brokers were busy doing those
5,000-, 10,000- and 15,000-square-foot deals.
Two
suburban office parks lost tenants occupying about 100,000-square-foot
each, and about 100,000 square feet of new space was completed
countywide.
Up went
the vacancy rate.
That was
confirmed by both Karnes Research and Carolinas Real Data, which rely on
slightly different methodologies.
Karnes
Research pegged the first-quarter rate at 14.6 percent, up from 14.2 in
the fourth quarter, and Carolinas Real Data figured it at 15.6 percent,
up from 15.3 percent in the fourth quarter.
Karnes
Research said countywide office vacancy rates peaked at 17.9 percent
during the early 1990s recession.
Both
firms counted more than 5.5 million square feet vacant countywide in the
first quarter.
If demand
continues at current levels and no major new office buildings are
started, Jenkins said, landlords should be able to reduce the oversupply
over the next couple of years.
"There
are not a lot of large chunks of space available in the suburban market
anymore," Bailey said. "Finding anything over 10,000 square feet is more
limited than it was a year ago."
Justin
Hunt, vice president of headquarters and international development at
the Charlotte Chamber, said, "I never think in terms of the local
vacancy rate. I think in terms of space a client can use."
While
landlords prefer to see every square foot occupied, the chamber says
having large blocks of space to show corporate relocation prospects
improves chances of attracting them.
Companies
that have made a decision to move typically want to do so quickly
without waiting for an office building to be constructed.
Hunt said
the chamber is talking with several out-of-town companies about
relocation.
"The
uptick in activity we're seeing isn't as fast as we would like to see,"
he said, "but it is happening."
Analyst
Brett Hicks, writing in Carolinas Real Data's first quarter office
report, said the war in
Iraq
and negative economic news stunted what looked like a promising start to
the year.
"Leasing
activity during January and February was stronger than activity at the
end of 2002," he wrote. "However, activity lessened significantly in
March (after the war started)."
Real
estate forecasters don't expect the Charlotte market to regain
pre-recession momentum until 2004, when economists say job generation
and business expansion could pick up.
Jenkins
said the
Charlotte area would be positioned to benefit from
such an upswing, thanks to its nationally competitive office rental
rates and available labor pool.
He and
other analysts believe the city will have to look for corporate tenants
other than Bank of America Corp. and Wachovia Corp. to fill about 1.3
million square feet of vacant space in the center city.
During
the late 1980s and 1990s, the banks' nearly insatiable appetite for
space fueled an office tower boom, but over the past two years they have
been consolidating office space uptown.
|